Ya know, I’m all for folks asking tough questions and coming up with even tougher answers, assuming this process of questioning and answering comes with enough humility to consider that other faithful Christians just might be doing the same kind of tough questioning and answering themselves — all the while claiming Jesus as Lord.
As some of you may know, this epistemological humility — not to mention Christian charity — has been missing from much recent conversation in The Episcopal Church, and from both sides of the aisle. The difference, however, is that some folks have decided that TEC no longer holds a valid claim to communion with Canterbury — that is, TEC has “walked away from the Anglican Communion.” Those who believe this to be true — predominantly from the more socially and theologically conservative side of the aisle — have decided that, in order for them to remain in communion with Canterbury, they must jump ship from TEC and hope to be picked up by the passing ships of other boundary-jumping bishops from around the globe. Most have been successful in this effort — being rescued by the likes of Uganda, Nigeria, and Recife (Brazil). Strangely enough, though, this emergence of trans-geographic dioceses has created its own tangled mess. Seems the schismatics are beginning to recognize the fruits of division — confusion, indirection, and fear.
One wonders how Archbishop Kolini of Rwanda can, with any integrity, suggest that there’s a unity which transcends ecclesial structure — the unity of ‘mission’ — our common concern for the world in which we live. If I understand our Christian unity correctly — and I’m open to being corrected here — it is rooted in the “gift” of unity we receive as baptized members of the Body of Christ — the unity of being “One in the Spirit” — what Anglicanism refers to as “communion.” They both work together — you can’t really choose one and not the other. Believe it or not, though, that’s just what the likes of CANA, ACN, AAC, and AMiA have done. They’ve chosen to abort the fundamental reality of our unity in Christ, and are attempting, now, to take the high road of Mission in Christ’s Name. Eventually — and you can count on this — some group among the schismatics will decide that a historically excluded group is worthy of affirmation and care, and some other group among the schismatics will disagree. Because they don’t agree on the trajectory of God’s love for the world — and because they’ve demonstrated a lack of belief and commitment to our spiritual unity in the Body of Christ — they will choose to further sever ties with each other, and further divide the Body they so strongly profess to care for.
How do you feel about worshiping in a church with people whose beliefs and/or behaviors you disagree with? Have you experienced this? How have you dealt with it before? Are there limits to your willingness to “stick together”? How do your understandings of God and Church play into it?
Read on, and see what you think. Peace, Paul
Jacksonville (Fla.) Times-Union
Jan. 20, 2007
Anglicans raise questions of unity
By JEFF BRUMLEY
The Times-Union
The Anglican conference concluding today in Jacksonville was described as Christian unity in action.
About 1,300 to 1,600 participants of the Anglican Mission in America conference shared a zeal for spreading the gospel and a repulsion from the Episcopal Church’s growing acceptance of openly gay clergy
and same-sex blessings.
But between workshops on topics like church planting and creating effective children’s ministries, the buzz among vendors’ tables and coffee kiosks often centered on where the whole Anglican experiment
in America is headed. With about a dozen national organizations representing Anglicans who have quit the Episcopal Church, plus nearly as many foreign bishops overseeing parishes in the U.S., many worry the movement is becoming irreparably fragmented. “It’s all part of the balkanization of the Episcopal Church,” said David Virtue of Virtueonline.org, an Internet-based Anglican news and commentary site that boasts 4 million readers.
Theologically conservative Episcopalians left the denomination after 2003 when an openly gay priest was elected the Episcopal bishop of New Hampshire. In doing so, they sought oversight from like-minded Anglican bishops in places like Africa, South America and Southeast Asia. On the First Coast [sic], former Episcopalians from more than a dozen congregations have accepted oversight from bishops in Kenya, Uganda, Rwanda and Brazil.
Meanwhile, at least 10 national Anglican organizations have been formed, including the Anglican Communion Network, the American Anglican Council, the Anglican Province of America and the Anglican Mission in America. Some fear the longer congregations are led by different foreign dioceses, the harder it will eventually become to draw them together under a common banner.
Anglican parishes are stuck in a “survival mode” as long as that fragmented state exists, said the Rev. Jim McCaslin, a priest who led All Souls in Mandarin out of the Episcopal Church and into a Ugandan diocese in 2006. The church also is one of about 20 in the Anglican Alliance of North Florida, and McCaslin is the leader of Anglican Communion Network congregations in the region. It is crucial that the communion’s world leaders create a new hierarchical structure for Anglicans in the U.S. and Canada - hopefully during their triennial meeting next month in Tanzania, McCaslin said. “If they don’t, that leaves you with a fractured church with unity in the gospel but no structural unity,” he said.
Such a new organization could exist beside the Episcopal Church within the Anglican Communion, Virtue and some priests at the convention said. But some of the overseas archbishops attending the Jacksonville conference hinted that Anglicans in America may have to adjust their expectations.
“To me, structure is the wrong way, the wrong direction,” Archbishop Emmanuel Kolini of Rwanda, founder of the Anglican Mission in America, told the Times-Union. Kolini said he believes an important kind of unity already exists - that which unites Christians from different denominations in fighting problems such as AIDS.
The Rev. Sam Pascoe, rector of the Kolini-led Grace Anglican Church in Orange Park, said a new denomination is necessary eventually. Otherwise “it’s just complete disintegration and everyone goes their own way and you end up with hundreds of different jurisdictions,” Pascoe said.